Penny Dreadful. The ultra-budget, thousands-of-cards Magic Online brewer's paradise with powerful cards, six free weekly tournaments, free 24/7 league, prizes, quarterly rotations, and a super friendly community.
-
How do I get started with Magic Online?
Check out the guide to Magic Online.
-
Card legality is set quarterly based on which cards are 2¢ or less at that time.
The best way to search legal cards is with Scryfall.
You can view the full legal cards list.
-
How do I find or brew a decklist?
Minimum 60 cards. Any number of basic lands. Max four of any other legal card. Sideboard of up to fifteen cards.
The best way to build decks is to use a search engine that supports Penny Dreadful legality (f:pd) like Scryfall.
Browse Decklists from tournaments, leagues and elsewhere
View the full legal cards list
-
How do I get a game and find other Penny Dreadful players?
To get a match in Magic Online go to Constructed, Specialty, Freeform Tournament Practice on Magic Online and create a Freeform game with "Penny Dreadful" in the comments.
To find the Penny Dreadful community join the Discord.
-
Leagues last for roughly a month. You may enter any number of times but only one deck at a time.
You play five matches per run. You can join the league at any time.
To find a game sign up and then create a game in Constructed, Specialty, Freeform Tournament Practice with "Penny Dreadful League" as the comment.
Top 8 finishers on each month's league leaderboard win credit with Cardhoarder.
-
We have six free-to-enter weekly tournaments with prizes from Cardhoarder.
They are hosted on Gatherling along with a lot of other player-run Magic Online events.
-
Legality is determined a week after the release of a Standard-legal set on Magic Online.
Prices are checked every hour for a week. Anything 2¢ or less for half or more of all checks is legal for the season.
Any version of a card on the legal cards list is legal.
The next rotation is in 12 weeks, 4 days.
Card | Bug | Severity | Read More |
---|---|---|---|
Wall of Roots | The mana abilities of Wall of Roots and Kozilek's Translator cannot be activated while paying the mana cost of a spell or ability. Players can still activate these abilities at any time that player has priority. | Disadvantageous | |
Laelia, the Blade Reforged | Laelia, the Blade Reforged doesn't trigger on Hideaway | Disadvantageous | |
Lake of the Dead | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
Snake Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Mutiny | Mutiny doesn't have clear targeting information. Workaround: the game log displays targets matching the order written on the card, and will highlight the appropriate creature when its name is hovered over with the mouse. | Graphical | |
Ripples of Undeath | Paying for ripples of undeath while wheel of sun and moon is in play locks the game. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Relic Crush | Relic Crush can target the same permanent twice. | Advantageous | |
Turn // Burn | Fuse cards such as Turn // Burn have a visual error when granted other abilities. | Graphical | |
Infernal Darkness | Infernal Darkness remembers the life loss payment for future mana payments | Disadvantageous | |
Volcano Hellion | Volcano Hellion's damage is capped at 255 | Disadvantageous | |
Abandoned Sarcophagus | Abandoned Sarcophagus exiles cards that you cycle | Disadvantageous | |
Enduring Renewal | Enduring Renewal prevents losing to decking | Advantageous | |
City of Brass | Drain Power does not function correctly when the targeted player controls City of Brass. | Unclassified | |
Desolate Lighthouse | Dredging using Desolate Lighthouse's ability while empty-handed lets the player avoid discarding | Advantageous | |
Vivien, Champion of the Wilds | If Vivien, Champion of the Wilds exiles a creature with flash, it incorrectly also displays that it has flash in blue text. | Graphical | |
Semblance Anvil | Semblance Anvil does not function when a split card is imprinted. | Disadvantageous | |
Peregrination | Spells like Cultivate fail to display the destination zones of the chosen lands in the game log. | Graphical | |
Guardian Project | Guardian Project does not draw a card if a face-down permanent (e.g. Morph) enters the battlefield if another is already in play. | Disadvantageous | |
Siphon Insight | Siphon Insight makes the targeted player skip their next draw step (avoidable) | Advantageous | |
Drain Power | Drain Power does not function correctly when the targeted player controls City of Brass. | Unclassified | |
Solemnity | Solemnity does not prevent a player from paying tribute cost, but the creature won't get the +1/+1 counter | Advantageous | |
Out of Time | Out of Time interacts incorrectly with characteristic-setting abilities | Advantageous | |
Choice of Damnations | Choice of Damnation allows the opponent to choose whether to sacrifice or lose life, except they cant choose to sacrifice. | Non-Functional ability | |
Terrarion | Terrarion can be sacrificed as part of the cost of the spell, but if the spell is undone before casting, terrarion will no longer provide a card when it goes to the graveyard. | Disadvantageous | |
Skull Storm | Skull Storm causes the game to restart when it resolves | Game Breaking | |
Entreat the Angels | When Entreat the Angels is on the stack with 0 chosen for X, the blue text that typically indicates the value of X does not appear. | Graphical | |
Amoeboid Changeling | Removing all creature types from a creature is displayed as if only the two leftmost creature types were removed | Graphical | |
Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker | If control of Grave Betrayal or Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker changes between a creature dying and the delayed EOT trigger going on the stack, the new controller gets the creature rather than the player who created the delayed trigger. | Disadvantageous | |
Consuming Tide | Consuming tide returns the chosen permanents, not all others. | Disadvantageous | |
Cultivate | Spells like Cultivate fail to display the destination zones of the chosen lands in the game log. | Graphical | |
Clone | Players are prompted to choose the replacement effect of cards such as Clone during the resolution of Show and Tell. | Unclassified | |
Drownyard Behemoth | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Mammoth Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Opposition Agent | Opposition Agent has no effect on Conflux | Disadvantageous | |
Show and Tell | Players are prompted to choose the replacement effect of cards such as Clone during the resolution of Show and Tell. | Unclassified | |
Careful Consideration | Copy spells that care about being cast during a main phase such as Careful Consideration sometimes do not confer the main phase bonus. | Unclassified | |
Tomorrow, Azami's Familiar | Tomorrow, Azami's Familiar puts both unchosen cards back on top of the library. | Disadvantageous | |
Grafdigger's Cage | If you manifest a creature with Grafdigger's Cage in play, it will be exiled. | Disadvantageous | |
Grafdigger's Cage | Grafdigger's Cage and Weathered Runestone don't prevent cards from entering the battlefield from the library if the cards are revealed from the top. | Disadvantageous | |
Grafdigger's Cage | Grafdigger's Cage does not stop Oath of Druids from putting creatures on the battlefield | Disadvantageous | |
Grafdigger's Cage | With Grafdigger's Cage on the battlefield, the trigger of Matter Reshaper does not put the card into your hand. | Unclassified | |
Academy Manufactor | Some cards with replacement effects can replace card draw when a card with Dredge is in the graveyard with various consequences | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Reyhan, Last of the Abzan | When Reyhan dies, it puts zero +1/+1 counters on target creature | Disadvantageous | |
Curse of Leeches | Curse of Leeches dies when it transforms into the front side. | Disadvantageous | |
Diabolic Servitude | Diabolic Servitude's second ability does not function. (When the creature put onto the battlefield with Diabolic Servitude dies, exile it and return Diabolic Servitude to its owner’s hand.) | Disadvantageous | |
Fork in the Road | Spells like Cultivate fail to display the destination zones of the chosen lands in the game log. | Graphical | |
Elder Deep-Fiend | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Goblin Electromancer | With two copies of Goblin Electromancer in play, splice costs are incorrectly calculated. | Unclassified | |
Deathmist Raptor | Deathmist Raptor doesn't trigger when it's discarded to pay the morph cost of a creature | Disadvantageous | |
Bala Ged Thief | When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone | Graphical | |
Field of the Dead | If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Reflecting Pool | Reflecting Pool does not get the ability to add any color of mana to your mana pool from Crumbling Vestige or Tainted Lands. | Disadvantageous | |
Wake to Slaughter | Wake to Slaughter exiles both the card put onto the battlefield AND the card put into hand | Disadvantageous | |
Leonin Arbiter | Leonin Arbiter behaves weirdly on Magic Online: if you want to pay 2 to search your library you must click the arbiter before you search | Graphical | |
Rags // Riches | If a commander is chosen for Riches in Rags // Riches, no other opponents need to choose a creature. | Disadvantageous | |
Retribution of the Ancients | Retribution of the Ancients doesn't allow you to activate it when you have no creatures with +1/+1 counters. | Disadvantageous | |
Channel | Casting or copying Channel on your opponent's turn lets you use the emblem on your next turn. | Advantageous | |
Mirror Match | Non-creature permanents that become creatures temporarily are incorrectly considered blocked by the token copies | Advantageous | |
Jace, the Mind Sculptor | Some cards don't reflect the player choices correctly in chat log | Graphical | |
Words of Worship | Words of Worship causes the game to restart when you activate it for the draw for turn | Game Breaking | |
Kamahl's Summons | Kamahl's Summons doesn't allow you to reselect a card to reveal if you deselect it | Disadvantageous | |
The First Eruption | The First Eruption Chapter III is Treated as a "may" ability but it is mandatory | Advantageous | |
Soul Ransom | Soul Ransom isn't sacrificed when it's ability is activated | Advantageous | |
Mindclaw Shaman | You are unable to cast split cards with Mindclaw Shaman's ability. | Disadvantageous | |
Dire-Strain Rampage | Targeting an indestructible land with Dire-Strain Rampage allows the controller of the land to search for two lands. | Advantageous | |
Compulsive Research | Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding in a specific case | Advantageous | |
As Foretold | Disrupting Shoal counters spells of any mana value when cast from As Foretold | Advantageous | |
As Foretold | As Foretold does not apply to cards able to be cast due to permission granted by other cards, such as Abandoned Sarcophagus and Harness the Storm | Disadvantageous | |
Weathered Runestone | Second Sunrise bringing back a Weathered Runestone will fail to return things below Weathered Runestone in the graveyard. | Advantageous | |
Weathered Runestone | Grafdigger's Cage and Weathered Runestone don't prevent cards from entering the battlefield from the library if the cards are revealed from the top. | Disadvantageous | |
Lazav, the Multifarious | If Lazav, Multifarious is a copy of another creature that references other copies of itself such as Myr Servitor, it will incorrectly refer to other copies of Lazav. | Unclassified | |
Omen Machine | Omen Machine forces previously exiled spells to be used when a target becomes available | Advantageous | |
Omen Machine | Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir incorrectly allows opponents to cast spells with Omen Machine. | Disadvantageous | |
Skullbriar, the Walking Grave | Skullbriar, the Walking Grave can cause the client to crash if it moves to the command zone with +1/+1 counters. | Game Breaking | |
Kodama's Reach | Spells like Cultivate fail to display the destination zones of the chosen lands in the game log. | Graphical | |
Fireball | Fireball cannot be cast with 0 targets when X = 0. | Disadvantageous | |
Umori, the Collector | The deckbuilder incorrectly shows that is Umori ineligible to be the companion for a Kindred-type deck. | Graphical | |
Commander's Plate | Commander's Plate gives protection from all colors outside of Commander. | Advantageous | |
Mystic Forge | Mystic Forge does not allow casting Zoetic Cavern as a Morph creature from the top of your library | Disadvantageous | |
Umbral Mantle | When you untap a mana-producing creature as part of cost to activate an ability, MTGO wrongly allows you to tap that creature for mana in the middle of paying the cost | Advantageous | |
Mogg Assassin | Mogg Assassin doesn't kill the opponent's creature on a won flip and doesn't always let both players select a target | Disadvantageous | |
Angelic Field Marshal | Angelic Field Marshal still grants a bonus to your commander when an opponent gains control of it. | Advantageous | |
Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger | Cards that are exiled by Ulamog, the Ceaseless Hunger incorrectly show association arrows while in the Exiled Zone. | Graphical | |
Blood Clock | Blood Clock and Umbilicus don't let you return permanent to hand | Advantageous | |
Barren Glory | Barren Glory does not check intervening if clause during resolution | Advantageous | |
Runed Halo | If a card is manifested and would normally require a choice as it enters the battlefield, it incorrectly prompts you for that choice | Advantageous | |
Bloodlord of Vaasgoth | Bloodlord of Vaasgoth does not display the blue text it grants other vampires. | Graphical | |
Eternal Scourge | Cards that can be cast from exile are incorrectly able to be cast while face down. | Advantageous | |
Wolfbitten Captive | If Heir to Falkenrath, Ecstatic Awakener, or Wolfbitten Captive activate their ability, then transform and transform back to the front side in some way, their ability can be activated again in the same turn. | Advantageous | |
Omnath, Locus of All | Omnath, Locus of All adds three colorless mana if a colorless card with the required mana symbols is revealed | Advantageous | |
Scythe of the Wretched | Unscythe, Killer of Kings and Scythe of the Wretched trigger when unequipped, bringing any dead creatures back | Advantageous | |
Distant Memories | Distant Memories lock the game at opponent's priority | Game Breaking | |
Tromokratis | Tromokratis can cause the game the game to soft-lock in multiplayer games | Game Breaking | |
Nylea, Keen-Eyed | Nylea, Keen-Eyed mills all non-creatures it reveals and does not put creatures it reveals into your hand | Disadvantageous | |
Patchwork Crawler | Patchwork Crawler doesn't have the activated abilities of cards it exiles. | Disadvantageous | |
Smallpox | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Vedalken Orrery | Chainer, Nightmare Adept can't cast cards using its ability during opponents turn when Vedalken Orrery is also in play. | Disadvantageous | |
Inquisition of Kozilek | Conceding while looking at an opponent's hand with Inquisition of Kozilek causes a game restart in multiplayer. | Game Breaking | |
The Mirari Conjecture | Premium versions of Sagas such as The Mirari Conjecture have some incorrect art assets. | Unclassified | |
Harmonic Prodigy | Shaman of the Great Hunt only puts one counter on creatures with Harmonic Prodigy in play | Disadvantageous | |
Harmonic Prodigy | Harmonic Prodigy causes creatures that are both shamans and wizards to trigger three times | Advantageous | |
Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir | Teferi, Mage of Zhalfir incorrectly allows opponents to cast spells with Omen Machine. | Disadvantageous | |
Falkenrath Gorger | Falkenrath Gorger doesn't trigger madness | Disadvantageous | |
Sword-Point Diplomacy | Sword-Point Diplomacy is buggy in 3+ player | Advantageous | |
Stinkweed Imp | Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing. | Advantageous | |
Conundrum Sphinx | Conundrum Sphinx does not draw card if guessed correctly | Unconfirmed | |
Metallic Mimic | If Metallic Mimic and a creature of the chosen type enter the battlefield at the same time, the system will incorrectly give that creature a +1/+1 counter | Advantageous | |
Horobi's Whisper | Splicing Horobi's Whisper does not exile cards from graveyard until the spell is cast - two Whispers can exile the same cards | Advantageous | |
Abundant Maw | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Rhythm of the Wild | Rhythm of the Wild incorrectly grants riot to creature cards that enter the battlefield as noncreatures such as Keranos, God of Storms. | Advantageous | |
Release the Ants | If a player has no cards left in their library, both players will lose a clash from cards such as Release the Ants. | Unclassified | |
Vexing Scuttler | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Mind Bend | Cards that ask you to choose "a basic land type or a color word" only let you choose a basic land type. | Disadvantageous | |
Sheltering Ancient | Sheltering Ancient's cumulative upkeep won't put the +1/+1 counter on a creature that already have +1/+1 counter, but you can still choose them | Advantageous | |
Nullstone Gargoyle | Nullstone Gargoyle counters all noncreature spells cast | Advantageous | |
Animar, Soul of Elements | Animar, Soul of Elements can cause slowdown with an excessive amount of counters on it. | Unclassified | |
Nahiri's Wrath | The prompt box for the additional cost of Nahiri's Wrath contains a grammatical error when selecting a single target. | Graphical | |
Mana Reflection | Mana Reflection doesn't double mana produced by mana abilities that provide mana in any combination of colors | Disadvantageous | |
Realmwalker | Realmwalker allows you to see the top card of your deck before you choose a creature type. | Advantageous | |
Bear Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Portent | Some cards don't reflect the player choices correctly in chat log | Graphical | |
Porphyry Nodes | Porphyry Nodes allows a creature to regenerate if it's tied for the least power. | Disadvantageous | |
Spell Crumple | There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves. | Unclassified | |
Frodo, Determined Hero | Frodo, Determined Hero also prevents damage on your opponent's turn | Advantageous | |
Decimator of the Provinces | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Yidaro, Wandering Monster | Yidaro, Wandering Monster's reanimation ability does not function | Disadvantageous | |
Pithing Needle | Avatars are incorrectly on the list of cards you can name with cards such as Pithing Needle. | Unclassified | |
Exhume | Exhume doesn't allow you to pick targets for Clones. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Thieving Sprite | When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone | Graphical | |
Karn Liberated | Restarting the game with Karn Liberated does not remove the City's Blessing. | Advantageous | |
Karn Liberated | If Karn Liberated restarts the game, its controller draws a card on their first turn. | Advantageous | |
Conspiracy Theorist | Conspiracy Theorist can exile cards with madness and then they can be played until end of the turn | Advantageous | |
Compost | Compost isn't triggered when an opponent only casts the nonblack half of a split card. | Disadvantageous | |
Wheel of Sun and Moon | If Wheel of Sun & Moon is enchanting both players and cards enter both players graveyard at the same time, the game crashes. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Provoke the Trolls | Cards that have an effect when something is dealt damage by the card do the effect despite damage prevention. | Advantageous | |
Island Sanctuary | Island Sanctuary's replacement effect is available if you draw a card during an opponents draw step | Advantageous | |
Sorin, Lord of Innistrad | If Sorin, Lord of Innistrad somehow becomes a creature, he cannot target himself with his ultimate ability. | Disadvantageous | |
Synthetic Destiny | Synthetic Destiny only puts one creature into play | Disadvantageous | |
Stolen Identity | When a player casts a spell with cipher such as Stolen Identity, the caster incorrect gains priority before it finishes resolving. | Unclassified | |
Collected Company | Collected Company does not allow you to put fewer than the maximum number of creatures onto the battlefield. | Disadvantageous | |
Szadek, Lord of Secrets | Szadek, Lord of Secrets won't deal any damage at all nor get its replacement effect when a "Damage can't be prevented" ability is active | Disadvantageous | |
Selvala, Explorer Returned | Selvala, Explorer Returned's ability can only be activated at instant speed | Disadvantageous | |
Orcish Spy | Orcish Spy and cards with similar abilities show the cards in alphabetical order, not the actual order | Disadvantageous | |
Phyrexian Revoker | If a card is manifested and would normally require a choice as it enters the battlefield, it incorrectly prompts you for that choice | Advantageous | |
Umbilicus | Blood Clock and Umbilicus don't let you return permanent to hand | Advantageous | |
Brothers Yamazaki | If one player controls two Brothers Yamazaki, and another player controls one, the "legend rule" continues to not apply. | Unclassified | |
Storage Matrix | Selecting yes to anything other than artifacts with two Storage Matrix in play causes the game to soft lock. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Armored Skyhunter | Armored Skyhunter removes your creatures when it's trigger resolves | Disadvantageous | |
Eel Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Vexing Sphinx | Vexing Sphinx's cumulative upkeep make you discard only one card regardless of the amount of age counters it has | Advantageous | |
Rogue Skycaptain | Rogue Skycaptain's upkeep cost is always {2}. | Advantageous | |
Founding the Third Path | Primal Wellspring doesn't copy spells cast by the third chapter of Founding the Third Path | Disadvantageous | |
Spider Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Lotus Vale | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
It of the Horrid Swarm | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Distended Mindbender | When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone | Graphical | |
Distended Mindbender | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Distended Mindbender | Distended Mindbender lets you skip choosing cards even if appropriate cards are available. | Advantageous | |
Mockery of Nature | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Invasion of Alara | Invasion of Alara spams the game log if daybound is in the game. | Graphical | |
Nazahn, Revered Bladesmith | Nazahn, Revered Bladesmith will sometimes give the equipment it finds to another player's hand. | Disadvantageous | |
Intuition | Intuition Behaves Strangely With Adventures (choose the spell half of the adventure from the drop down to avoid) | Graphical | |
Estrid, the Masked | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Florian, Voldaren Scion | Agonizing Remorse + Florian, Voldaren Scion puts the opponent's hand on the bottom of their library if the opponent is dealt no damage on that turn | Advantageous | |
Sublime Archangel | If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Retriever Phoenix | Some cards with replacement effects can replace card draw when a card with Dredge is in the graveyard with various consequences | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Myriad Construct | When Myriad Construct is the only legal target of a storm card, it only produces tokens once, no matter how many times it is targeted. | Disadvantageous | |
Rotting Rats | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Matter Reshaper | With Grafdigger's Cage on the battlefield, the trigger of Matter Reshaper does not put the card into your hand. | Unclassified | |
Riders of Gavony | Riders of Gavony gives protection to all permanents. | Advantageous | |
Meteor Storm | Meteor Storm only discards one card | Advantageous | |
Sibsig Icebreakers | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Containment Priest | Containment Priest exiles Theros Gods even when their devotion isn't met. | Advantageous | |
Containment Priest | If Containment Priest and any other creatures (not cast) ETB at the same time, all the other creatures get exiled | Disadvantageous | |
Multani's Presence | Multani's Presence incorrectly draws cards off copies of spells that are countered | Advantageous | |
Multani's Presence | Multani's presence also draws cards when a spell does not resolve because there is no more valid target. | Advantageous | |
Knowledge Pool | With multiple Knowledge Pools in play, casting a spell from hand lets you cast a spell from each Pool. | Advantageous | |
Knowledge Pool | Knowledge Pool doesn't let you cast spells exiled under it unless you have an untapped mana source. | Advantageous | |
Glimpse of Tomorrow | If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Glimpse of Tomorrow | Glimpse of tomorrow doesn't reveal nonpermanent cards. | Graphical | |
Kjeldoran Outpost | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
Thada Adel, Acquisitor | Thada Adel, Acquisitor shows opponent's hand as well as library when searching their library | Advantageous | |
Cairn Wanderer | Instead of looking at GY, Cairn Wanderer looking at creatures on battlefield | Advantageous | |
Drake Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Indrik Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Grenzo, Dungeon Warden | Grenzo, Dungeon Warden's ability can put cards such as Progenitus; that have a replacement effect preventing them from being in graveyards; onto the battlefield. | Advantageous | |
Soulflayer | Soulflayer doesn't show that it has gained variations of abilities, such as "Hexproof from Black". | Graphical | |
Crab Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Ashiok's Erasure | Ashiok's Erasure and Ixalan's Binding don't prevent the opponent from casting copies of the spells they've exiled. | Disadvantageous | |
Miasmic Mummy | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Heart of Yavimaya | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
Riptide Replicator | Riptide Replicator tokens use incorrect art and incorrectly display they have the changeling ability. | Graphical | |
Phage the Untouchable | Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing. | Advantageous | |
Primal Surge | If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Play with Fire | Cards that have an effect when something is dealt damage by the card do the effect despite damage prevention. | Advantageous | |
Skull Raid | Skull raid draws cards if the discarded cards go to the battlefield | Advantageous | |
Academic Dispute | If you choose not to give targeted creature reach with Academic Dispute, you do not learn | Disadvantageous | |
Soldevi Excavations | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
Battlefield Thaumaturge | Battlefield Thaumaturge wrongly handle how much discount a spell get if it being targeted more than once by that spell | Advantageous | |
Grave Betrayal | If Grave Betrayal changes owners with its trigger on the stack, the new controller incorrectly becomes the owner of the trigger. | Unclassified | |
Grave Betrayal | If control of Grave Betrayal or Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker changes between a creature dying and the delayed EOT trigger going on the stack, the new controller gets the creature rather than the player who created the delayed trigger. | Disadvantageous | |
Crovax the Cursed | Certain card's abilities set the number of counters on them to one rather than adding one counter | Disadvantageous | |
Evershrike | If you activate Evershrike's ability multiple times before having it get reanimated, each trigger will let you attach an aura. | Advantageous | |
Boar Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Concerted Effort | Some protection abilities granted by Concerted Effort are not shown visually on creatures | Graphical | |
Kiora, Master of the Depths | Kiora, Master of the Depths incorrectly allows taking MDFCs where one side is a land, and does not count it toward the total taken | Advantageous | |
Oath of Druids | Grafdigger's Cage does not stop Oath of Druids from putting creatures on the battlefield | Disadvantageous | |
Second Sunrise | Second Sunrise bringing back a Weathered Runestone will fail to return things below Weathered Runestone in the graveyard. | Advantageous | |
Emrakul, the Promised End | Casting two copies of Emrakul, the Promised End does not give the opponent two extra turns. | Unclassified | |
Zur's Weirding | Zur's Weirding forces dredging to occur. | Advantageous | |
Pia's Revolution | Pia's Revolution creates an incorrect prompt while also being nonfunctional. | Disadvantageous | |
Cut // Ribbons | Split cards such as Cut // Ribbons are reported as 3 cards in the chat log. | Graphical | |
Mephitic Ooze | Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing. | Advantageous | |
Ulamog's Despoiler | Creatures entering the battlefield as a copy of Ulamog's Despoiler do not trigger its ability. | Disadvantageous | |
Ever After | There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves. | Unclassified | |
Primal Amulet | If you cast a card you don't own with Primal Wellspring, the copy is cast by the card's owner. | Disadvantageous | |
Primal Amulet | Primal Wellspring doesn't copy spells cast by the third chapter of Founding the Third Path | Disadvantageous | |
Strongarm Tactics | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Lavinia of the Tenth | Lavinia of the Tenth detains nonland permanents forever if controller dies | Advantageous | |
Dauntless Escort Avatar | Dauntless Escort Avatar causes the game to draw caused by infinite exalted triggers | Game Breaking | |
Mindblaze | Mindblaze allows you to choose zero | Advantageous | |
Repudiate // Replicate | If split cards such as Repudiate // Replicate are exiled face down, they are sometimes still revealed to all players. | Unclassified | |
Shared Fate | Zones that cards appear in due to the replacement ability of Shared Fate are incorrect. | Graphical | |
Ixalan's Binding | Ashiok's Erasure and Ixalan's Binding don't prevent the opponent from casting copies of the spells they've exiled. | Disadvantageous | |
Necra Sanctuary | Necra Sanctuary does not cause a player to lose 3 life if you control both a green and white permanent. | Disadvantageous | |
Pollen Lullaby | Pollen Lullaby does not display the rules text stating that the creature doesn't untap. | Graphical | |
Earsplitting Rats | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Muldrotha, the Gravetide | Muldrotha, the Gravetide does not allow you to cast cards from your graveyard with As Foretold. | Disadvantageous | |
Stronghold Rats | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Chainer, Nightmare Adept | Chainer, Nightmare Adept can't cast cards using its ability during opponents turn when Vedalken Orrery is also in play. | Disadvantageous | |
Ivorytusk Fortress | Ivorytusk Fortress doesn't untap anything | Disadvantageous | |
Sakashima the Impostor | Witness Protection causes the game to lock when you have Sakishima the Imposter become a Legitimate Businessperson while it clones another nonlegendary card you control. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Illusionary Mask | Illusionary Mask doesn't function. | Disadvantageous | |
Battle for Bretagard | Battle for Bretagard doesn't let you choose different tokens that share certain creature types. | Disadvantageous | |
Rigo, Streetwise Mentor | Rigo, Streetwise Mentor's ability only triggers once regardless of the number of players attacked. | Disadvantageous | |
Crackling Drake | Creatures with variable power and toughness such as Crackling Drake are not correctly updated in the reveal zone. | Graphical | |
Heir of Falkenrath | If Heir to Falkenrath, Ecstatic Awakener, or Wolfbitten Captive activate their ability, then transform and transform back to the front side in some way, their ability can be activated again in the same turn. | Advantageous | |
Alter Reality | When you change the color in a card's text, the card won't show the new chosen color in the cards itself, in the tooltip, and not in the zoomed version | Disadvantageous | |
Seasons Past | There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves. | Unclassified | |
Treefolk Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Zhur-Taa Druid | Zhur-Taa Druid does not deal damage when tapped for its ability | Advantageous | |
Sauron's Ransom | Sauron's Ransom shows whether face down cards are white-bordered and whether they have "save-targets" enabled | Advantageous | |
Overwhelming Splendor | Creatures with ascend can still grant the City's Blessing with Overwhelming Splendor on the battlefield. | Disadvantageous | |
Kunoros, Hound of Athreos | Kunoros's static ability prevents cards below it in the graveyard from entering the battlefield when reanimated together. | Disadvantageous | |
Grotesque Hybrid | Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing. | Advantageous | |
Herald of Torment | Bestowed creatures dont trigger Hateful Eidolon | Disadvantageous | |
Gideon's Intervention | Casting a second copy of Gideon's Intervention causes the first to allow the named card to deal damage. | Disadvantageous | |
Charmed Pendant | Charmed Pendant's ability doesn't add mana to mana pool | Disadvantageous | |
Jester's Scepter | Jester's scepter can't counter spells with the same name as card exiled | Disadvantageous | |
Felidar Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Platinum Emperion | If you control Platinum Emperion you cannot even pay 0 life for costs. | Disadvantageous | |
Samurai of the Pale Curtain | Samurai of the Pale Curtain does not exile tokens. | Disadvantageous | |
Phyrexian Portal | Phyrexian Portal's prompt message is ambiguous whether it's the pile to be exiled or to be searched for, and the rest of the searched pile is put on the bottom instead of being shuffled back in | Disadvantageous | |
Tainted Specter | Tainted Specter's ability locks the game for the chosen player. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Scorched Ruins | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
Mist of Stagnation | Mist of Stagnation doesn't allow players to choose untapped permanents, will soft-lock the game if there are not enough tapped permanents in the field to fulfil the requirements, and in random cases requires less number of tapped permanents than what should normally be required | Game Breaking | |
Godsire | The tokens created by Godsire doesn't clearly stating nor indicating its colors | Graphical | |
Krark's Thumb | Krark's Thumb prints all coin flips of its owner three times | Graphical | |
Umbra Mystic | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Linessa, Zephyr Mage | Linessa, Zephyr Mage allows Opp to choose the same card for artifact and creature. | Disadvantageous | |
Floodtide Serpent | Instead of bouncing an enchantment, attacking with Floodtide Serpent shows you all zones. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Oriss, Samite Guardian | Using Oriss, Samite Guardian's Grandeur ability during controller's precombat main phase will not allow controller to attack that turn. | Disadvantageous | |
Doppelgang | Doppelgang restarts the game if X is too high | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Balduvian Trading Post | Cards like Lake of the Dead sacrifice less lands if multiple enter at the same time, and not all land sacrifices can be fulfilled | Advantageous | |
Hateful Eidolon | Bestowed creatures dont trigger Hateful Eidolon | Disadvantageous | |
Disciple of Phenax | When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone | Graphical | |
Glamerdye | When you change the color in a card's text, the card won't show the new chosen color in the cards itself, in the tooltip, and not in the zoomed version | Disadvantageous | |
Conflux | Opposition Agent has no effect on Conflux | Disadvantageous | |
Puca's Mischief | Puca's Mischief requires controlling a creature to function | Disadvantageous | |
Boonweaver Giant | Boonweaver Giant puts auras into play even if it's not on the battlefield | Advantageous | |
Witness Protection | Witness Protection causes the game to lock when you have Sakishima the Imposter become a Legitimate Businessperson while it clones another nonlegendary card you control. | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Octopus Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Hyena Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Damping Engine | Damping Engine activated ability is broken. Sacrificing a permanent pops up another trigger to sac another permanent. | Advantageous | |
Crystal Spray | Cards that ask you to choose "a basic land type or a color word" only let you choose a basic land type. | Disadvantageous | |
Realms Uncharted | Spells like Cultivate fail to display the destination zones of the chosen lands in the game log. | Graphical | |
Creeping Dread | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Liquid Fire | Liquid Fire doesn't let you choose how to deal damage - it all goes to player | Disadvantageous | |
Moonring Mirror | Moonring Mirror Gives lets you switch back on the same upkeep | Advantageous | |
Anointed Procession | Some cards with replacement effects can replace card draw when a card with Dredge is in the graveyard with various consequences | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Nether Traitor | Nether Traitor triggers when it goes to the graveyard alongside other creatures. | Advantageous | |
Ecstatic Awakener | If Heir to Falkenrath, Ecstatic Awakener, or Wolfbitten Captive activate their ability, then transform and transform back to the front side in some way, their ability can be activated again in the same turn. | Advantageous | |
Dreams of the Dead | Dreams of the Dead giving Cumulative Upkeep isn't reflected on a creature | Graphical | |
Keranos, God of Storms | Rhythm of the Wild incorrectly grants riot to creature cards that enter the battlefield as noncreatures such as Keranos, God of Storms. | Advantageous | |
Volrath's Shapeshifter | Volrath's Shapeshifter does not function as intended. | Disadvantageous | |
Cunning Lethemancer | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Sekki, Seasons' Guide | Spirit tokens created by Sekki, Seasons' Guide are not considered to have the same name. | Unclassified | |
Search the City | Search the City's cast trigger does not trigger | Non-Functional ability | |
Wretched Gryff | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Voracious Cobra | Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing. | Advantageous | |
Rain of Gore | Rain of Gore is affecting Lifelink. | Advantageous | |
Lashweed Lurker | Undoing the sacrifice cost of an emerge ability behaves incorrectly | Advantageous | |
Ixidron | If a card is manifested and would normally require a choice as it enters the battlefield, it incorrectly prompts you for that choice | Advantageous | |
Sanguine Sacrament | There are known issues with giving flashback to a spell that is put on the bottom of a library as it resolves. | Unclassified | |
Freyalise's Winds | Anytime a permanent with a wind counter would be untapped outside of the untap step with Freyalise's Winds in play, a wind counter is removed rather than it becoming untapped wrongly | Disadvantageous | |
Secret Salvage | Secret Salvage does not add the cards found from the library to the revealed zone. | Graphical | |
Whims of the Fates | Whims of the Fates Causes client crashes | Game Breaking | |
Ice Cave | Ice Cave requests an incorrect mana amount to counter a spell on the stack | Non-Functional ability | |
Pattern Matcher | Pattern Matcher Fails to find valid matches | Disadvantageous | |
Shaman of the Great Hunt | Shaman of the Great Hunt only puts one counter on creatures with Harmonic Prodigy in play | Disadvantageous | |
Spectral Shift | When you change the color in a card's text, the card won't show the new chosen color in the cards itself, in the tooltip, and not in the zoomed version | Disadvantageous | |
The Great Aurora | The Great Aurora shuffles tokens into your library that you can then draw. | Advantageous | |
Caller of the Hunt | Caller of the Hunt doesn't allow you to pick a creature type | Disadvantageous | |
Null Profusion | Null Profusion triggers when another player casts its owner's cards | Advantageous | |
Unscythe, Killer of Kings | Unscythe, Killer of Kings and Scythe of the Wretched trigger when unequipped, bringing any dead creatures back | Advantageous | |
Dripping Dead | Creatures with an ability that destroys creatures that they deal combat damage to ignore Phasing. | Advantageous | |
Entrails Feaster | Certain card's abilities set the number of counters on them to one rather than adding one counter | Disadvantageous | |
Structural Collapse | Structural Collapse doesn't sacrifice the chosen permanents | Disadvantageous | |
Amulet of Safekeeping | Amulet of Safekeeping does not trigger on the copies of a spell with storm | Disadvantageous | |
Skinshifter | The ability context menu of Skinshifter is displayed incorrectly. | Graphical | |
Kozilek's Translator | The mana abilities of Wall of Roots and Kozilek's Translator cannot be activated while paying the mana cost of a spell or ability. Players can still activate these abilities at any time that player has priority. | Disadvantageous | |
Pyxis of Pandemonium | If multiple copies of Pyxis of Pandemonium are on the battlefield, it is difficult to determine where cards are associated. | Graphical | |
Chancellor of the Forge | If a lot of triggers (20+) go on the stack, the game may reset | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
Liege of the Hollows | Liege of the Hollows' death trigger doesn't function | Disadvantageous | |
Breaching Leviathan | Breaching Leviathan does not force the creature to remain tapped for a turn. | Unclassified | |
Trait Doctoring | Cards that ask you to choose "a basic land type or a color word" only let you choose a basic land type. | Disadvantageous | |
Whim of Volrath | Cards that ask you to choose "a basic land type or a color word" only let you choose a basic land type. | Disadvantageous | |
Varchild's War-Riders | Varchild's War-Riders does not create the opponent tokens | Advantageous | |
Tangleclaw Werewolf | Fibrous Entangler (Flipped Tangleclaw Werewolf) tries to force players who it is not attacking in multiplayer to block it, locking the game as they cannot make a legal block | Avoidable Game Breaking | |
High Seas | High Seas only affects red creature spells. | Disadvantageous | |
Withdraw | Withdraw is able to target the same creature twice. | Advantageous | |
Eland Umbra | Removing all abilities from the creature enchanted by an aura with Totem Armor removes the Totem Armor too | Disadvantageous | |
Forbidden Ritual | Forbidden RItual only allows you to do the first option: if you choose not to do the first effect, you do the effect you chose, and then have to choose again | Advantageous | |
Mindlash Sliver | You can choose to discard the non-creature side of an Adventure card during effects in which each player must discard a card | Advantageous | |
Sages of the Anima | Sages of the Anima puts the non-creature cards on top of the library instead of the bottom. | Disadvantageous | |
Warbreak Trumpeter | Warbreak Trumpeter's unmorph ability doesn't create tokens. | Disadvantageous |